Sold for $995,000: A Historic East Moriches Property Finds Its New Owner

By Marina Putova | Luxury Waterfront Real Estate Specialist

There is something special about helping a family sell a home that has been part of a community's history. I am excited to announce the successful sale of 428 Montauk Highway, East Moriches, NY, which closed for $995,000.

East Moriches continues to attract buyers seeking a blend of historic charm, waterfront lifestyle, and small-town Long Island living. This remarkable property stood out for its unique character, spacious layout, and exceptional location.

A Home with Character and History

Located in the heart of East Moriches, this property offered a rare opportunity to own a piece of local history. The home featured timeless architectural details, generous living spaces, and the charm that today's buyers are increasingly searching for.

Historic homes like this one are not just houses—they tell a story. From the craftsmanship to the location, every detail contributed to its appeal in today's competitive market.

Why Buyers Love East Moriches

East Moriches continues to be one of Long Island's hidden gems. Residents enjoy:

• Access to beautiful waterfront areas
• Close proximity to the Hamptons
• Local restaurants and shops
• Boating and outdoor recreation
• A peaceful South Shore lifestyle

To understand why 428 Montauk Highway is part of the East Moriches Historic District, it helps to know a little about what this designation means — and why it matters.

For the owner of 428 Montauk Highway, this means enjoying both the beauty and prestige of a landmark home — while contributing to the preservation of one of Long Island’s most charming and historically rich communities.
​​​​​​​

Real Estate in East Moriches

While the rolling farmland, vintage churches and tree-lined lanes evoke a simpler time, East Moriches’s real-estate landscape is very much 21st century. A cozy early-1900s ranch near Hart Cove might list for under $500,000; a restored and expanded farmhouse from the same era often commands closer to $800,000. Along the coastline, sprawling properties with water access and acreage can fetch $1.2 million or more—and still remain far more affordable than similarly sized homes just five miles west in the Hamptons, where comparable homes can top $3 million.

Current market data underscore this dynamic. According to one reputable source, the median sold home price in East Moriches was around $790,000 in June 2025 — a gain of about 6% from the prior year. On another measurement, a recent dataset shows the median sale price at $1,308,750, marking a dramatic year-over-year rise. Redfin

What this means: East Moriches is still one of the South Shore’s last relatively “affordable” enclaves before you cross into the high-priced Hamptons. For buyers seeking historic charm, acreage, and privacy — yet conscious of budget — it’s a compelling alternative.
​​​​​​​

A Blue Ribbon Education: East Moriches School District

Families in East Moriches benefit from the highly rated East Moriches Union Free School District, earning an overall “A” from Niche. Both the elementary and middle schools are rated A‑, while Center Moriches High School boasts an A‑ rating and 9/10 for college readiness from GreatSchools.

With a graduation rate over 90% and many students moving on to top Long Island colleges like Stony Brook University, the district combines academic excellence with a close-knit, supportive community—making East Moriches a truly desirable place to call home.
​​​​​​​

Dining and Main Street Charm

While neighboring Center Moriches attracts visitors with its historic Main Street shops and cafés, East Moriches offers a quieter, more relaxed scene—yet it is not without its culinary highlights.
​​​​​​​

ITA Kitchen Waterfront East Moriches (Italian American Food) 1.2 Miles 3 minutes

At the heart of the hamlet is ITA Kitchen Waterfront East Moriches, part of a popular Long Island restaurant group. This location serves Italian-American cuisine with a creative twist, from pesto risotto balls to ricotta gnocchi, and features a spacious outdoor patio overlooking Tuthill Cove and Atlantic Avenue Park, making it one of the area’s most scenic dining destinations.
​​​​​​​

Tony's Sushi & Steakhouse (Hibachi Asian Experience) 0.1 Mile 1 Minute

For other local favorites, Tony’s Sushi & Steakhouse offers a hibachi-style experience just a minute away, providing residents and visitors alike with a variety of flavorful options within walking distance.

From historic streetscapes to waterfront dining, East Moriches blends small-town charm with gourmet appeal, making it a delightful place to live—and to eat.
​​​​​​​

Hikes, Trails, and Local Parks

For those who love the outdoors, East Moriches offers plenty of natural escapes. Just west in Center Moriches, Webby’s Park features a playground and public beach, perfect for families and casual strolls along the water.

Closer to home, Terrell River County Park provides a more serene experience, with over two miles of hiking trails that wind along the river and through wooded areas, ideal for walking, jogging, or simply enjoying nature. Whether it’s a weekend adventure or a daily retreat, the hamlet’s parks and trails make it easy to embrace the outdoors without leaving town.
​​​​​​​

Terrell River County Park  (Park, Hiking Trail) 3.1 Miles 6 Minutes from 428 Montauk Highway East Moriches.

Few would argue that East Moriches attracts residents who value preserving history over promoting rapid growth. Newcomers might feel as though they’ve stepped back in time—and that’s exactly the point. From its preserved architecture to its protected coastlines, the hamlet remains a living snapshot of early 20th-century Long Island, lovingly maintained by those determined to keep its timeless charm alive.

Residents can also enjoy the coastal lifestyle, with Moriches Bay, marinas, and water sports just a short walk away. The area offers plenty of nearby attractions, including Kaler’s Pond, Soldiers & Sailors Park, ocean and bay beaches, golf courses, theaters, galleries, restaurants, antique shops, farmers markets, wineries, and easy access to both the Hamptons and North Fork.

For those seeking a home that combines historic character, modern comforts, and a prime location, 428 Montauk Highway presents a rare opportunity to embrace the full East Moriches lifestyle—where history, community, and coastal living converge.

Marina Putova 
Luxury Waterfront Real Estate
South Shore Long Island Specialist
Coldwell Banker M&D Good Life
Coastal Estates • Waterfront Homes